Citation: LU Tian, CHEN Fei-Wu. Comparison of Computational Methods for Atomic Charges[J]. Acta Physico-Chimica Sinica, ;2012, 28(01): 1-18. doi: 10.3866/PKU.WHXB2012281 shu

Comparison of Computational Methods for Atomic Charges

LU Tian ,
CHEN Fei-Wu

1.
School of Chemical and Biological Engineering, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing 100083, P. R. China

Received Date: 13 September 2011
Available Online: 31 October 2011
Fund Project: 国家自然科学基金(20773011)资助项目 (20773011)

Atomic charge is one of the simplest and the most intuitive description of charge distribution in chemical systems. It has great significance in theory and in practical applications. In this article we introduce the basic principles and special characteristics of twelve important computational methods for the determination of atomic charges and compare their pros and cons from various aspects by considering a large number of instances. These methods include Mulliken, atomic orbitals in molecules (AOIM), Hirshfeld, atomic dipole moment corrected Hirshfeld population (ADCH), natural population analysis (NPA), Merz-Kollmann (MK), atom in molecules (AIM), Merck molecular force field 94 (MMFF94), AM1-BCC, Gasteiger, charge model 2 (CM2), and charge equilibration (QEq). Finally some general suggestions on how to choose a proper method for practical applications are given.
- Atomic charge,
- Computational chemistry,
- Population analysis,
- Electronegativity,
- Electrostatic potential
1. [1]
  (1) Qian, B. H.; Ma,W. X.; Lu, L. D.; Yang, X. J.;Wang, X. Acta Phys. -Chim. Sin. 2010, 26, 610. [钱保华, 马卫兴, 陆路德, 杨绪杰, 汪信. 物理化学学报, 2010, 26, 610.]
2. [2]
  (2) Zheng,W. R.; Xu, J. L.; Xiong, R. Acta Phys. -Chim. Sin. 2010, 26, 2535. [郑文锐, 徐菁利, 熊瑞. 物理化学学报, 2010, 26, 2535.]
3. [3]
  (3) Shen, T.; Du, F. P.; Liu, T.; Yao, G.W.;Wu, Z.; Fang, M. M.; Xu, X. J.; Lu, H. Z. Acta Phys. -Chim. Sin. 2011, 27, 1831. [申涛, 杜凤沛, 刘婷, 姚广伟, 吴峥, 方萌萌, 徐筱杰, 路慧哲. 物理化学学报, 2011, 27, 1831.]
4. [4]
  (4) Zhou, J. J.; Chen, H. M.; Xie, G. R.; Ren, T. R.; Xu, Z. H. Prog. Chem. 1998, 10, 55. [周家驹, 陈红明, 谢桂荣, 任天瑞, 许志宏. 化学进展, 1998, 10, 55.]
5. [5]
  (5) Ji, G. D.; Zhao, Y. H.; Yuan, X. J. Northeast Normal Univ. (Natural Science Edition) 1998, 47. [籍国东, 赵元慧, 袁星. 东北师范大学学报(自然科学版), 1998, 47.]
6. [6]
  (6) Ding, Y. F.; Zhang, Y.; Zhang, D. H.; Li, Z. P. Acta Phys. -Chim. Sin. 2010, 26, 1651. [丁元法, 张跃, 张大海, 李仲平. 物理化学学报, 2010, 26, 1651.]
7. [7]
  (7) Laio, A.; VandeVondele, J.; Rothlisberger, U. J. Phys. Chem. B 2002, 106, 7300.
8. [8]
  (8) Pipek, J.; Mezey, P. G. J. Chem. Phys. 1989, 90, 4916.
9. [9]
  (9) Elstner, M.; Porezag, D.; Jungnickel, G.; Elsner, J.; Haugk, M.; Frauenheim, T.; Suhai, S.; Seifert, G. Phys. Rev. B 1998, 58, 7260.
10. [10]
  (10) Giesen, D. J.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Phys. Chem. 1995, 99, 7137.
11. [11]
  (11) Giesen, D. J.; Hawkins, G. D.; Liotard, D. A.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. Theor. Chem. Acc. 1997, 98, 85.
12. [12]
  (12) Li, J. B.; Hawkins, G. D.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1998, 288, 293.
13. [13]
  (13) Thompson, J. D.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Phys. Chem. A 2004, 108, 6532.
14. [14]
  (14) Meister, J.; Schwarz,W. H. E. J. Phys. Chem. 1994, 98, 8245.
15. [15]
  (15) Cramer, C. J. Essentials of Computational Chemistry, 2nd ed.; JohnWiley & Sons:West Sussex, 2004; pp 309-324.
16. [16]
  (16) Jensen, F. Introduction to Computational Chemistry, 2nd ed.; JohnWiley & Sons:West Sussex, 2007; pp 293-304.
17. [17]
  (17) Young, D. C. Computational Chemistry; JohnWiley & Sons: New York, 2001; pp 99-105.
18. [18]
  (18) Cioslowski, J. ElectronicWavefunction Analysis. In Encyclopedia of Computational Chemistry; Schleyer, P. v. R. Ed.; JohnWiley & Sons:West Sussex, 1998; Vol. 2, pp 892-905.
19. [19]
  (19) Mulliken, R. S. J. Chem. Phys. 1955, 23, 1841.
20. [20]
  (20) Mulliken, R. S. J. Chem. Phys. 1955, 23, 1833.
21. [21]
  (21) Mulliken, R. S. J. Chem. Phys. 1955, 23, 2338.
22. [22]
  (22) Bachrach, S. M. Population Analysis and Electron Densities from Quantum Mechanics. In Reviews in Computational Chemistry; Lipkowitz, K. B., Boyd, D. B. Eds.; VCH Publishers: New York, 1994; Vol. 5, pp 171-227.
23. [23]
  (23) Clark, A. E.; Sonnenberg, J. L.; Hay, P. J.; Martin, R. L. J. Chem. Phys. 2004, 121, 2563.
24. [24]
  (24) Martin, F.; Zipse, H. J. Comput. Chem. 2005, 26, 97.
25. [25]
  (25) Wiberg, K. B.; Rablen, P. R. J. Comput. Chem. 1993, 14, 1504.
26. [26]
  (26) Lu, H. G.; Dai, D. D.; Yang, P.; Li, L. M. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2006, 8, 340.
27. [27]
  (27) Hirshfeld, F. L. Theor. Chem. Acc. 1977, 44, 129.
28. [28]
  (28) Lu, T.; Chen, F.W. J. Theor. Comput. Chem. Accepted.
29. [29]
  (29) Reed, A. E.;Weinstock, R. B.;Weinhold, F. J. Chem. Phys. 1985, 83, 735.
30. [30]
  (30) Besler, B. H.; Merz, K. M., Jr.; Kollman, P. A. J. Comput. Chem. 1990, 11, 431.
31. [31]
  (31) Bader, R. F.W.; Beddall, P. M. J. Chem. Phys. 1972, 56, 3320.
32. [32]
  (32) Halgren, T. A. J. Comput. Chem. 1996, 17, 520.
33. [33]
  (33) Halgren, T. A. J. Comput. Chem. 1996, 17, 616.
34. [34]
  (34) Jakalian, A.; Bush, B. L.; Jack, D. B.; Bayly, C. I. J. Comput. Chem. 2000, 21, 132.
35. [35]
  (35) Jakalian, A.; Jack, D. B.; Bayly, C. I. J. Comput. Chem. 2002, 23, 1623.
36. [36]
  (36) Gasteiger, J.; Marsili, M. Tetrahedron 1980, 36, 3219.
37. [37]
  (37) Li, J. B.; Zhu, T. H.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Phys. Chem. A 1998, 102, 1820.
38. [38]
  (38) Rappe, A. K.; ddard,W. A. J. Phys. Chem. 1991, 95, 3358.
39. [39]
  (39) Cusachs, L. C.; Politzer, P. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1968, 1, 529.
40. [40]
  (40) Stout, E.W.; Politzer, P. Theor. Chem. Acc. 1968, 12, 379.
41. [41]
  (41) Doggett, G. J. Chem. Soc. A 1969, 229.
42. [42]
  (42) Christoffersena, R. E.; Baker, K. A. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1971, 8, 4.
43. [43]
  (43) Bickelhaupt, F. M.; van Eikema Hommes, N. J. R.; Fonseca Guerra, C.; Baerends, E. J. Organometallics 1996, 15, 2923.
44. [44]
  (44) Weinhold, F. Natural Bond Orbital Methods. In Encyclopedia of Computational Chemistry; Schleyer, P. v. R. Ed.; JohnWiley & Sons:West Sussex, 1998; Vol. 2 pp 1792-1811.
45. [45]
  (45) Glendening, E. D.; Badenhoop, J. K.; Reed, A. E.; Carpenter, J. E.; Bohmann, J. A.; Morales, C. M.;Weinhold, F. NBO, Version 5.0, 2001. http://www.chem.wisc.edu/-nbo5/.
46. [46]
  (46) Liu,W.; Li, L. Theor. Chem. Acc. 1997, 95, 81.
47. [47]
  (47) Sanchez-Portal, D.; Artacho, E.; Soler, J. M. Solid State Commun. 1995, 95, 685.
48. [48]
  (48) Sanchez-Portal, D.; Artacho, E.; Soler, J. M. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 1996, 8, 3859.
49. [49]
  (49) Bader, F.W. Atoms in Molecules: A Quantum Theory; Oxford University Press: New York, 1994.
50. [50]
  (50) Nalewajski, R. F.; Parr, R. G. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2000, 97, 8879.
51. [51]
  (51) Davidson, E. R.; Chakravorty, S. Theor. Chem. Acc. 1992, 83, 319.
52. [52]
  (52) Chirlian, L. E.; Francl, M. M. J. Comput. Chem. 1987, 8, 894.
53. [53]
  (53) Breneman, C. M.;Wiberg, K. B. J. Comput. Chem. 1990, 11, 361.
54. [54]
  (54) Sigfridsson, E.; Ryde, U. J. Comput. Chem. 1998, 19, 377.
55. [55]
  (55) Bayly, C. I.; Cieplak, P.; Cornell,W.; Kollman, P. A. J. Phys. Chem. 1993, 97, 10269.
56. [56]
  (56) Dewar, M. J. S.; Zoebisch, E. G.; Healy, E. F.; Stewart, J. J. P. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1985, 107, 3902.
57. [57]
  (57) Storer, J.W.; Giesen, D. J.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Comput. -Aided Mol. Des. 1995, 9, 87.
58. [58]
  (58) Li, J. B.;Williams, B.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Chem. Phys. 1999, 110, 724.
59. [59]
  (59) Thompson, J. D.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Comput. Chem. 2003, 24, 1291.
60. [60]
  (60) Winget, P.; Thompson, J. D.; Xidos, J. D.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Phys. Chem. A 2002, 106, 10707.
61. [61]
  (61) Kalinowski, J. A.; Lesyng, B.; Thompson, J. D.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Phys. Chem. A 2004, 108, 2545.
62. [62]
  (62) Olson, R. M.; Marenich, A. V.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2007, 3, 2046.
63. [63]
  (63) Kelly, C. P.; Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2005, 1, 1133.
64. [64]
  (64) Mayer, I. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1983, 97, 270.
65. [65]
  (65) Sanderson, R. T. Science 1951, 114, 670.
66. [66]
  (66) Rappe, A. K.; Casewit, C. J.; Colwell, K. S.; ddard,W. A.; Skiff,W. M. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1992, 114, 10024.
67. [67]
  (67) Mortier,W. J.; Ghosh, S. K.; Shankar, S. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1986, 108, 4315.
68. [68]
  (68) Cioslowski, J. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1989, 62, 1469.
69. [69]
  (69) Cioslowski, J. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1989, 111, 8333.
70. [70]
  (70) Szabo, A.; Ostlund, N. S. Modern Quantum Chemistry, 1st rev ed.; Dover Publications: New York, 1989.
71. [71]
  (71) Hariharan, P. C.; Pople, J. A. Theor. Chem. Acc. 1973, 28, 213.
72. [72]
  (72) Hehre,W. J.; Ditchfield, R.; Pople, J. A. J. Chem. Phys. 1972, 56, 2257.
73. [73]
  (73) Frisch, M. J.; Pople, J. A.; Binkley, J. S. J. Chem. Phys. 1984, 80, 3265.
74. [74]
  (74) Frisch, M. J.; Trucks, G.W.; Schlegel, H. B.; et al . Gaussian 03, Revison E.01; Gaussian Inc.:Wallingford, CT, 2004.
75. [75]
  (75) Lu, T. Multiwfn, Version 2.1.2; 2011. http://Multiwfn.codeplex. com.
76. [76]
  (76) Keith, T. A. AIMALL, Version 10.05.04, 2010.
77. [77]
  (77) Lu, H. G. AOIM, Version 1.1, 2006; http://faculty.sxu.cn/luhg/ aoim.html.
78. [78]
  (78) Avogadro: an Open-Source Molecular Builder and Visualization Tool, Version 1.0.3, 2011.
79. [79]
  (79) Case, D. A.; Darden, T. A.; Cheatham, T. E. C. III., et al . AmberTools, Version 1.5; 2011.
80. [80]
  (80) Schäfer, A.; Horn, H.; Ahlrichs, R. J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 97, 2571.
81. [81]
  (81) PETRA Manual. http://www2.ccc.uni-erlangen.de/software/ petra/manual (accessed Sep 12, 2011).
82. [82]
  (82) Marsili, M.; Gasteiger, J. Croat. Chem. Acta 1980, 53, 601.
83. [83]
  (83) The Open Babel Package, Version 2.3.0; 2010. http://openbabel. sourceforge.net.
84. [84]
  (84) Sanner, M. F. J. Mol. Graph. Modal. 1999, 17, 57.
85. [85]
  (85) Woods, R. J.; Khalil, M.; Pell,W.; Moffat, S. H.; Smith, V. H. J. Comput. Chem. 1990, 11, 297.
86. [86]
  (86) Hehre,W. J.; Stewart, R. F.; Pople, J. A. J. Chem. Phys. 1969, 51, 2657.
87. [87]
  (87) Binkley, J. S.; Pople, J. A.; Hehre,W. J. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1980, 102, 939.
88. [88]
  (88) Krishnan, R.; Binkley, J. S.; Seeger, R.; Pople, J. A. J. Chern. Phys. 1980, 72, 650.
89. [89]
  (89) Dunning, J. T. H. J. Chem. Phys. 1989, 90, 1007.
90. [90]
  (90) Kendall, R. A.; Dunning, T. H.; Harrison, R. J. J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 6796.
91. [91]
  (91) Becke, A. D. Phys. Rev. A 1988, 38, 3098.
92. [92]
  (92) Perdew, J. P. Phys. Rev. B 1986, 33, 8822.
93. [93]
  (93) Becke, A. D. J. Chem. Phys. 1993, 98, 1372.
94. [94]
  (94) Patel, S.; Brooks, C. L. Mol. Simul. 2006, 32, 231.
95. [95]
  (95) Stewart, J. J. P. Int. J. Quantum Chem. 1996, 58, 133.
96. [96]
  (96) Biegler-König, F.W. J. Comput. Chem. 2000, 21, 1040.
97. [97]
  (97) Biegler-König, F.W.; Bader, R. F.W.; Tang, T. H. J. Comput. Chem. 1982, 3, 317.
98. [98]
  (98) Sanville, E.; Kenny, S. D.; Smith, R.; Henkelman, G. J. Comput. Chem. 2007, 28, 899.
99. [99]
  (99) Maseras, F.; Morokuma, K. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1992, 195, 500.
1. [1]
  Yanan Jiang , Yuchen Ma . Brief Discussion on the Electronic Exchange Interaction in Quantum Chemistry Computations. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 10-15. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202402058
2. [2]
  Hongting Yan , Aili Feng , Rongxiu Zhu , Lei Liu , Dongju Zhang . Reexamination of the Iodine-Catalyzed Chlorination Reaction of Chlorobenzene Using Computational Chemistry Methods. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 16-22. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202403010
3. [3]
  Renqing Lü , Shutao Wang , Fang Wang , Guoping Shen . Computational Chemistry Aided Organic Chemistry Teaching: A Case of Comparison of Basicity and Stability of Diazine Isomers. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 76-82. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202404119
4. [4]
  Yi Li , Zhaoxiang Cao , Peng Liu , Xia Wu , Dongju Zhang . Revealing the Coloration and Color Change Mechanisms of the Eriochrome Black T Indicator through Computational Chemistry and UV-Visible Absorption Spectroscopy. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 132-139. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202405154
5. [5]
  Yiying Yang , Dongju Zhang . Elucidating the Concepts of Thermodynamic Control and Kinetic Control in Chemical Reactions through Theoretical Chemistry Calculations: A Computational Chemistry Experiment on the Diels-Alder Reaction. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(3): 327-335. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202309074
6. [6]
  Qian Huang , Zhaowei Li , Jianing Zhao , Ao Yu . Quantum Chemical Calculations Reveal the Details Below the Experimental Phenomenon. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(3): 395-400. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202309018
7. [7]
  Congying Lu , Fei Zhong , Zhenyu Yuan , Shuaibing Li , Jiayao Li , Jiewen Liu , Xianyang Hu , Liqun Sun , Rui Li , Meijuan Hu . Experimental Improvement of Surfactant Interface Chemistry: An Integrated Design for the Fusion of Experiment and Simulation. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(3): 283-293. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202308097
8. [8]
  Xuyang Wang , Jiapei Zhang , Lirui Zhao , Xiaowen Xu , Guizheng Zou , Bin Zhang . Theoretical Study on the Structure and Stability of Copper-Ammonia Coordination Ions. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(3): 384-389. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202309065
9. [9]
  Shule Liu . Application of SPC/E Water Model in Molecular Dynamics Teaching Experiments. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(4): 338-342. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202310029
10. [10]
  Baitong Wei , Jinxin Guo , Xigong Liu , Rongxiu Zhu , Lei Liu . Theoretical Study on the Structure, Stability of Hydrocarbon Free Radicals and Selectivity of Alkane Chlorination Reaction. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 402-407. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202406003
11. [11]
  Hongyi Zhang , Zhihong Shi , Zhijun Zhang . A New Strategy for “De-formulized” Calculation of Dynamic Buffer Capacity in Analytical Chemistry Education. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(3): 390-394. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202309030
12. [12]
  Huiying Xu , Minghui Liang , Zhi Zhou , Hui Gao , Wei Yi . Application of Quantum Chemistry Computation and Visual Analysis in Teaching of Weak Interactions. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 199-205. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202407011
13. [13]
  Ji-Quan Liu , Huilin Guo , Ying Yang , Xiaohui Guo . Calculation and Discussion of Electrode Potentials in Redox Reactions of Water. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(8): 351-358. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202401031
14. [14]
  Yu'ang Liu , Yuechao Wu , Junyu Huang , Tao Wang , Xiaohong Liu , Tianying Yan . Computation of Absolute Electrode Potential of Standard Hydrogen Electrode Using Ab Initio Method. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 215-222. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202407112
15. [15]
  Fei Xie , Chengcheng Yuan , Haiyan Tan , Alireza Z. Moshfegh , Bicheng Zhu , Jiaguo Yu . d带中心调控过渡金属单原子负载COF吸附O₂的理论计算研究. Acta Physico-Chimica Sinica, 2024, 40(11): 2407013-. doi: 10.3866/PKU.WHXB202407013
16. [16]
  Ping Ye , Lingshuang Qin , Mengyao He , Fangfang Wu , Zengye Chen , Mingxing Liang , Libo Deng . 荷叶衍生多孔碳的零电荷电位调节实现废水中电化学捕集镉离子. Acta Physico-Chimica Sinica, 2025, 41(3): 2311032-. doi: 10.3866/PKU.WHXB202311032
17. [17]
  Zhenming Xu , Yibo Wang , Zhenhui Liu , Duo Chen , Mingbo Zheng , Laifa Shen . Experimental Design of Computational Materials Science and Computational Chemistry Courses Based on the Bohrium Scientific Computing Cloud Platform. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 36-41. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202403096
18. [18]
  Hua Hou , Baoshan Wang . Course Ideology and Politics Education in Theoretical and Computational Chemistry. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(2): 307-313. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202309045
19. [19]
  Liuxie Liu , Jing He , Jiali Du , Shuang Mao , Qianggen Li . Extension of Computational Chemical-Assisted Dipole Moment Measurement Experiment. University Chemistry, 2025, 40(3): 363-370. doi: 10.12461/PKU.DXHX202407108
20. [20]
  Ling Fan , Meili Pang , Yeyun Zhang , Yanmei Wang , Zhenfeng Shang . Quantum Chemistry Calculation Research on the Diels-Alder Reaction of Anthracene and Maleic Anhydride: Introduction to a Computational Chemistry Experiment. University Chemistry, 2024, 39(4): 133-139. doi: 10.3866/PKU.DXHX202309024

Get Citation

PDF

XML

Metrics

PDF Downloads(3141)
Abstract views(6932)
HTML views(433)

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

1.
沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院沈阳 110142